Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


We've not killed Bill, protest STV bosses

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 October 2009
IT WAS a decision which led many to reach for the remote control and change channels. But STV are now considering bringing back hit shows such as The Bill, following complaints from viewers.
While defending Scottish Television's new strategy of ditching popular network drama in favour of home-grown programmes, Rob Woodward, the chief executive of STV, said yesterday that shows which were the former staple of TV schedules may yet return to Scottish screens.

In recent months, STV has refused to screen popular ITV dramas such as Doc Martin and Midsomer Murders in order to save money and provide slots for new Scottish programmes. That has led to complaints from viewers and a £38 million lawsuit from ITV.

However, at a press conference yesterday to unveil STV's autumn schedule, Mr Woodward said the programme cuts were not final and would be reviewed. In the future, hit network dramas could be shown on STV in a different time slot.

He said: "We have been very careful not to make strident announcements and so we will remain open-minded about what the schedule looks like. In the future, you may have hit shows both on STV and ITV but they might not be shown at the same time. That is the level of refinement that we are working towards."

Asked if they would consider bringing back shows such as The Bill, he said: "Yes, we will. We have a very open mind about what the schedule will look like."

Bobby Hain, STV's managing director of broadcasting, said: "We have never said we are never going to consider these programmes again. It's not a final decision."

STV has already seen its average daily audience drop by 12 per cent in the past year, losing viewers at more than double the rate of ITV. In recent weeks, it has defended renewed claims that its Scottish substitutes are faring poorly with viewers who have the digital choice of switching to the main ITV station.

Yesterday, Mr Woodward said STV hopes to secure funding to produce a one-hour six o'clock news programme for Scotland, estimated to cost around £15m a year.

An Ofcom Scotland spokesman said they had received 30 complaints to date about STV opting out of the ITV network.

Robert Beveridge, a lecturer in media policy at Edinburgh Napier University, said: "STV's decision to make and broadcast more programmes for and about Scotland and the Scottish perspective on the world is deserving of our full support."

Charles Fletcher, head of industry development firm Caledonia Media, said: "

STV actually responded to what viewers and the industry has called for over many years – more locally produced programmes about Scotland.

"Perhaps ITV can learn some lessons from the way this has been handled in Glasgow. They may wish they had such a strong management team running their business."

War and emotional peace at centre of STV's winter schedule

SCOTS at War, a three-part documentary series about soldiers in Afghanistan, is at the heart of STV's new winter schedule unveiled yesterday.

The documentary follows soldiers from the Royal Regiment of Scotland during the vicious fighting in Helmand province over the summer months, as well as examining the role of Scots soldiers in history.

Other highlights include The Search for Sherlock Holmes, which will follow David Hayman, the actor and TV policeman, as he goes on the trail of the world's most famous detective. The documentary will be part of a Sherlock Holmes evening.

The broadcaster will also tackle the issue of mental health in a revealing six-part series, Make Me Happier – presented by Lorraine Kelly – in which a group of Scots with emotional health issues attempt to improve their lives.

After the controversy of denying Scots viewers network drama, STV will offer them a series unavailable on the network. Underbelly is a hit Australian drama about a spate of infamous gangland killings in Melbourne and has been described as an Antipodean Sopranos.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 October 2009 11:47 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: ITV
 
1

Justin Timbercake,

19/10/2009 22:58:53
If you think STV is bad now, just remember, it would be a million times worse in an independant Scotland.
2

Fifi la Bonbon,

20/10/2009 00:14:01
Does that mean I won't be able to post a link any more to Armando Iannucci's "And that's except for viewers in Scotland, who've got their own programmes?"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7scMC7YSDQ
3

,

20/10/2009 00:31:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Fifi la Bonbon,

20/10/2009 00:55:44
#1 - if you were a REAL Scot you'd learn to love programmes with that actor out of Taggart talking about haggis, and one of the Singh Kohli brothers telling us how Irn Bru is made. Do you not love your country enough to watch kailyard telly and not complain about it? I personally can't wait for the next series of Paul Coia's Hill Challenge with Dougie Donnelly, and the Dougie Donnelly Chat Show with Paul Coia.
5

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 00:58:29

The STV should have done it right in the first place or not at-all!, STV means Scotland, but the STV choose to put films on, that no-one want to see, not even the English, that came out the Ark, and produced 'God knows where'?
What did the STV Management expect?, not a 'Gold-Medal', that's for sure!


6

Fifi la Bonbon,

20/10/2009 01:01:23
Actually, Paul Coia's doing quite well. Apparently he presents Smooth Radio London’s Drivetime show each week day from 4pm till 8pm.
7

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 01:55:17

A Classroom of 10year olds would do the job better, and would do Scotland Proud, if they had to present Scottish Television, and their programming.
It is a case of unbelievable,...'D'oh!, when the Management of the STV choose to televise programmes, of films, that would even bore the dead.

8

Aman,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 05:10:54
Maybe STV realise that in the 21st century viewers can watch The Bill at few days later on ITV3, ITV1 London,via a download. None of which bring advertising revenue to STV, especially as the regular Bill viwers turn away from STV to another channel. Only 30 complaints say STV. That's those who bothered to communicate, as it seemed a pretty worthless effort.
I may write now to make it 31.
9

Royster,

20/10/2009 05:40:19
#3. Edward, Stop spouting such drivel. Broadcasting, like most things in an independent Scotland, will be under huge financial pressure. Poor economy of scale, lower revenue base with overheads remaining the same.
10

Saul Tyre,

20/10/2009 06:18:04
Justin Timberlake, Fifi la Bonbon & Royster,

All together now:

"WE CANNAE DAE IT!"
11

Saul Tyre,

20/10/2009 06:22:32
New Labour's inofficial slogan to improve Scotland's lot, as endored by Justin Timberlake, Fifi la Bonbon & Royster:

"IT'S EASIER SAID THAN DONE."

12

Saul Tyre,

20/10/2009 06:24:36
Justin Timberlake, Fifi la Bonbon & Royster and their advice to the Scottish electorate:

"VOTE NEW LABOUR FOR MORE OF THE SAME."
13

StuartAD,

West Lothian 20/10/2009 06:31:24
We were both looking forward watching to Saturday night out in Auchtermuchty, now it seems we will have to watch that comedy: Dr. Martin, or MidsomerMurders. Pity we cannot see what happened to Mrs. Mckenzie's cat.
14

Royster,

20/10/2009 06:50:17
Saul Tyre. I'm glad you admit it is easier said than done. All the economic arguments for independence are built on sand. As for the SNP's defence policy, that's hilarious. Can't wait to see the joke media policy.
15

Xena - Warrior Princess,

20/10/2009 07:15:30
I don't believe for one minute that it was only 30 complaints. I sent an email registering my disgust at removing high quality programmes like Midsomer Murders, I also said that they were more likely to lose money as virtually no-one would be watching. Thank Goodness for Virgin Channel 853 where you can watch the programmes that STV had ditched.
16

Ex SNP Voter,

Buchan 20/10/2009 07:25:58
An hour long Scottish news? They have got to be kidding 30 minutes and they are already scrapping the barrel for stories......It sounds to me like Alex Salmond has stationed a man inside STV to push this rubbish.
17

Ex SNP Voter,

Buchan 20/10/2009 07:29:41
Saul Tyre I thought the SNP were in government in Scotland? Are you still trying to blame new Labour for everything? Get a backbone and accept the SNP aren't all they say they are.....

18

Douglas,

Bathgate 20/10/2009 07:39:42
I'm looking forward to watching Underbelly again with different adverts.
19

Saul Tyre,

20/10/2009 07:44:27
#14

At least the SNP's defence policy doesn't include useless nuclear missiles controlled by Washington. What defence policy would YOU advocate for a nation of 5 million people?
20

Saul Tyre,

20/10/2009 07:49:25
#17

I have to agree with you on that one; two years is more than enough time to rectify fifty years of Labour ineptitude.

I've applied for a backbone but they put me on the waiting list behind the Labour MPs who backed Tony Blair's Iraq adventure.
21

Royster,

20/10/2009 07:51:20
#19. That's the whole point. You can't have a credible defence policy for a nation of 5m. You can have one for a nation of 56m though. It's down to resources and what you can get for - say - 2% percent of GDP. All these small nations get conquered in large wars. As for Trident, not a huge fan. It's sort of all or nothing.
22

Tracy C,

Aberdeen 20/10/2009 08:03:26
Really looking foward to seeing Underbelly on STV although it will be interesting to see how much of each programme ends up on the cutting room floor!!!
23

Anna nexr door,

20/10/2009 08:04:35
Everyone, can we just realise the buffoon at 1 is English, he lives in England, and he is scared sh!tless that Scotland gets to go it,s own way.
He is so scared that Englands meal ticket is going to become independant in the next few years, he has to resort to writeing the complete drivel on everything to do with Scotland/SNP/independance.
He is a fool,he can only be pityed as like the chumps Royster and the "EX" SNP voter, who says he,s from Buchan!
Aye right!
They never answer the question that if Scotland is such a basket case economicily then WHY does England not free it,s self from the sponging little grubby wasters that we are?
24

Anna nexr door,

20/10/2009 08:09:12
21 Eh? "You can't have a credible defence policy for a nation of 5m"
So the defence forces of Israel, Denmark, Switzerland, Norway, Ireland, Finland (some of these are members of NATO)are not credible?
Once again you fail!
25

Royster,

20/10/2009 08:27:11
#24. Of course the defence forces of Ireland, Denmark, Norway, and Finland do not have credible defence forces - ie they are not capable of defending their countries by themselves. They have to rely on others or try to stay out of any argument (not a bad idea) and hope the tanks don't roll their way. Switzerland - at a push - has some good terrain, money and training to back it up and Israel is a completely different story (I don't think even the SNP want to build up an Israeli style defence force).
26

jdships,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 08:29:18
Why can't some people have the manners to stick to debating/answering the article written by Stephen McGinty.
If you want to discuss politics do so on the appropriate thread - please !
27

Royster,

20/10/2009 08:36:18
Yes. A bit off message.
28

Jam Tarts 1874,

On the Rebound 20/10/2009 08:43:23
Just can't get enough of that bagpipe & haggis TV, bring it on!
29

AIasdair,

20/10/2009 08:43:31
#25, Shoogles - Joe, why are you pretending to come from Leith? Why are you such a liar?
30

Ugly George,

20/10/2009 08:50:22
3 Edward
"Your completely clueless of what an Independent Scotland's broadcast media would be like"

Isn't everybody?
31

Alice Cooper,

20/10/2009 09:01:41
i remember when STV would announce "This is scottish television,your indipendant television station"
why did they stop that? or was it dropped when the oil was discovered?
there is a station called tartan tv and here is the link,some would say they have better progs than STV or EBC
http://www.tvguide.com/detail/tv-show.aspx?tvobjectid=194971&more=ucepisodelist&episodeid=4957416
its an aberdeen based company,also look in the news section on their link ,its got a story about how the tories may rip up the bbc charter
http://www.c21media.net/mediabase/company.asp?company=1473
32

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 20/10/2009 09:20:51
Bin boring Bill and his fantasy policing, and bring on Sgt. Eros' erotorubrub of drug dealin' detectives, the polack pole dancing cartel, the sisterhood of the Broch, the exclusive peterhead billionaire super-pelagic set. Don't knock Portknockie till you've tried it. Sex has never smoldered more in the Silvered City where crime always pays.

Finbar Marine Film never not has a casting couch and you'll find us in the Prince of Wales or Saucey Mary's when its open late enough. Most credit cards accepted for our healthy raging megalomania as we've ships to build too.
33

Rosscobhoy,

20/10/2009 09:35:14
When Scotland is independent i'll still watch most of my telly on sky digital as the terrestrial channels are mostly rubbish. Life on Mars, Peep Show and Shameless are the only programmes i feel were worth watching. From 5 channels in about 10 years. Great.
34

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 09:38:19
4 Fifi overdoses on the Cringe.
The Bill ? whae in their right mind is gaunnie miss THAT ?
35

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 09:41:02
26 - yep and maist o' the countries you name have a higher standard of livin than Scotland. But never mind, who needs quality life styles when we have Trident ?
36

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 09:44:11
Ditching the Bill would not be a great loss these days. It turned into a completely ridiculous soap opera years ago. I stopped watching it when a PC was depicted fire-bombing his own station. The final straw was when another PC stood outside his station with an automatic rifle, shooting at anyone who dared to come out.

I'd far prefer a documentary on the war or Sherlock Holmes. I think they could find something more cheerful than a program about people with mental problems though---and as for an Aussie version of The Sopranos, let's just leave that kind of thing to the Americans shall we?
37

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 09:49:16
37 it's the Jump the Shark syndrome (a one-time handy website which itself Jumped the Shark after being taken over).
Re Sherlock Holmes BBC 4 had an evening dedicated to Conan Doyle, good stuff and that channel produced A. McCall Smith's documentary about 'Ossian' MacPherson - now those are the type of progs worth paying a license fee for.
38

cabrach loon,

inverness 20/10/2009 09:51:21
Sorry but one can access all the mindless violence and never ending policier programs through satellite. In order to get Scottish content I mostly have to watch Alba even though I do not have the Gaelic. I do expect Scotland to provide some Scottish culture even though to their everlasting shame it seems homegrown Scots are ashamed to be Scottish! The European and communist countries do far better at retaining national identity and pride.
There is more to it than getting drunk at football matches which is what the English identity seems to typify / Scotland generally does better than that but there is still room for more Scots TV. Taggart, Rebus, are fine but more history, travelogues and documentaries will help without boring the anglophil viewers.
39

letmein,

paisley 20/10/2009 09:54:37
Popular ITV drama, Midsomer Murders. You have got to be kidding, this is real murder. (to watch)
I see rufus is still a stick of the dip variety.

The Bill was the only soap that we watched, instead of the rubbish like coronation st and eastbenders.
40

mr broon,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 09:54:45
"The standard of programming is dire! The schedules are cluttered up with Police dramas, Police documentaries, soaps, reality shows, and inane competition shows."

(Source: TV critic of the London Evening Standard
recently commenting on ITV1 Carlton and ITV1 Weekend)

41

Nellie,

Liverpool 20/10/2009 09:55:35
23 Anna nexr door

"WHY does England not free it's self from the sponging little grubby wasters that we are?"

Had you not considered that, since we, the English Scots, Welsh and N Ireland, were made one nation by consent and there is no appetite among the majority of people living in Scotland to "go it alone", it might be undemocratic to cast it Scotland adrift? Just vbecause a minority of Scots want total independence doesn't mean Scotland should be be! Indeed, lets see just how well, or not, the SNP does at the next General Election ...
42

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 10:06:16
X Factor, The Bill, Emmie , Corrie, maist of the Saturday evening stuff (bar Harry Hill).
Jeez, How'll we manage withoot them ?
43

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 10:08:35
42 - Liverpool, another city known for its connections tae the Orange Order
44

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 10:10:29
42 and of course we'd be missin oot on the UK democracy eg; an unelected Head of State, a PM who wisnae elected intae that office...the Hoose o' Lords....
45

Angus of the Isles,

20/10/2009 10:18:17
#42. Can you please expand on your theory of "consent."



Royster, Finland seemed to do rather well against Russia twice, as did Iceland against Rule Britannia in the Cod Wars.

Big bullies always get there comeuppance, the UK is now an international joke. Remember the Iranians hijacking Britains finest in the Gulf and then sending them home in pink underwear. A joke, like you.
46

Nellie,

Liverpool 20/10/2009 10:36:09
44 Pilrig.

Too true, unfortunately. The only good thing about them are their bands but now when they are marching. You see, Pilrig, you should nae judge a book by its cover.

45 The Head of State (The Queen) has no power; therefore, it is an irrelevance to discussion about democracy. (I'm a nationalist anyway, or I would be if practically all non-Monarch heads of States, Presidents, all seem a bunch of money, power grabbing shysters ... unlike the British Monarch, whose very existence brings in Millions of $$s every year from tourism; so there is one benefit to having a powerless "unelected" head of state.)

The House of Lords doesn't have to be elected because it doesn't pass the Laws - the Commons does that. The Lords acts as a consultative body (the non-hereditary peers are usually experts in their fields, as they also hold in check the Commons and the Government who, without the Lords power to delay the passing of Laws, could quite easily extend the life of a Government indefinitely, exactly how the Nazis did in the 1930's. Indeed, there seemed a risk of that happening in the 1970s when Tony Benn was advocating the demise of the Lords without a replacement and the extension of a Government in office for 10 years instead of the current 5 years. Personally, I'd like to see the Lords replaced with an elected body, of appointed representatives (as they are in the Lords) but reflecting the proportions of votes cast in an election.

46 The union was agreed by both the English and Scottish Parliaments, which were probably the nearest you could get to democracy in the World at that time.

Happy now?
47

Nellie,

Liverpool 20/10/2009 10:44:59
44 Pilrig

As well as its connections with the Orange Order, the area of Netherton in Liverpool is also known for having the highest concentration of Roman Catholics outside of Ireland.
48

,

20/10/2009 10:50:54
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
49

Jimmy Fae the West,

In The Land of Green Ginger. 20/10/2009 10:55:30
Re #1Justin Timbercake, 19/10/2009 22:58:53
If you think STV is bad now, just remember, it would be a million times worse in an independant Scotland.
________________________________

If your are not enjoying Scotland now, just remember, it will get a million times worst for you in a prosperous Liberated nation! Are you going to bring the troubles of Northern Ireland to Scotland?
The BILL is utter drivel and escapism for Ex-Londoners out here in the Yorkshire Sticks. I cannot even grasp what it means to you apart from escaping to the institutional sanctuary of independent British Empire Capital for a few minutes?

How very sad! VOTE SNP.
50

ACM,

Bearsden 20/10/2009 11:15:26
Some of the programmes that replaced my favourites are quite good but they shouldn't be shown in place of them. They should be additional to them and STV can remove some of the other rubbish it broadcasts. Did anyone see the programme about 'growing apples in Hertfordshire'? I can't wait for it to be repeated.

Never mind the complaints to Ofcom. How many were made to STV directly?
51

Angus of the Isles,

20/10/2009 11:20:20
#47 Your ignorant grasp of history is as fragile as your hold on sanity. Time for some medication.



#50 So much for the retirement of AM2. The poor sod has become even more rabid.
52

Jimmy Fae the West,

in the Land O' Green Ginger. (HULL) 20/10/2009 11:20:51
Re #47Nellie, Liverpool 20/10/2009 10:36:09
The Head of State (The Queen) has no power; therefore, it is an irrelevance to discussion about democracy. (I'm a nationalist anyway, or I would be if practically all non-Monarch heads of States, Presidents, all seem a bunch of money, power grabbing shysters ... unlike the British Monarch, whose very existence brings in Millions of $$s every year from tourism; so there is one benefit to having a powerless "unelected" head of state.)
Happy now?
_____________________________
Whoah, Nellie! Whoah.

Are you seriously advocating that we replace the Queen with our own Eiffel Tower? That gets more foreign tourists than the Queen! The Palaces that pulls in the tourists would be much better cared for and far better without the Millions we give to the massive royal family each week in unemployment benefits.

PS the Royals are working for themselves on the side, should we report them and have their benefits stopped?

On Topic, have you seen the ITV offering today? Cringeworthy 5'9" Philip Scoffield laughing nervously at vulgar sexist jokes from pre-pubescent 50 year old women followed by Loose-women making more vulgar sexist jokes about their men's private parts followed by an hour of fashion and Make-up, followed by a Alan Titmarsh then Midsomer Murders, then a Cookery Show in place of The Hour?

And someone thinks that is entertainment! Great TV. There is no way the Scottish show the Hour show can be a poor substitute for any of those!
53

Laird O'Gorgie,

20/10/2009 11:31:57
STV is exactly the same as the SNP. Garbage in, garbage out.
The key word in both cases is mediocre and a good example is Swinney the SNP's business "expert", a man that cannot even deliver basic systems like broadband or digital TV to his own constitunecy.
54

lyn,,

Perth 20/10/2009 11:39:33
Why don't these people up the top listen to what viewers want. God its not rocket science. Instead of seening that drivel James Bonnd once agian after the X Factor on Sunday night put on a decent/modern movie for the family to watch.
Works well in Australia on a Sunday night with local tv stations with the ratings war for the 8.30pm slot. If you want us to stay out of the pubs get your act into gear ITV.
55

coreservers,

20/10/2009 11:54:49
sorry Nellie #47, the union was agreed between the two parliaments, however the scottish parliamentarains had "accepted" gifts and moenys from the english parliament. and it lead to nearly 50 years of uprisings and dissent. STV however has shot itself in the foot by droping things like doc martin, in this digital age, when we can just switch to itv london, wales etc. they should have created a subsudiary channel like BBC alba, which is actually very good
56

Jimmy Fae the West,

In the Land O' Green Ginger. (HULL) 20/10/2009 12:38:07
The British Broadcasting service has Labour's genius John McFall on now giving his scriptures yet again. McFall was on the BBC scotchland politics-scotchland (see they do cater) the other day making a complete pillock of himself hilariously telling the Orange Lodge listeners that he felt pysically sickened on hearing Salmond likening himself to divine Biblical figures such as nelson Mandella and Ghandi? Glenn Campbell nods in agreement before turning to the Tory in another studio and asking if he was comfortable being so close to the SNP! campbell earlier asks Salmond the same stupid question three times (like an automaton) without once acknowledging the answer.
Watch the BBC shame here;
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/the_politics_show_scotland
57

DAVID,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 12:38:45
STV will learn the hard way. Viewers will switch off and especially those who have access to Sky / Virgin who will simply turn to the national versions to view what they want.

Unless, of course, the SNP decide to block this consumer choice and force us all to watch rubbish like River City, a 26 week series on the Scots who fought General Franco, a 52 week series on the Scots who liberated Iraq and all those exciting Scottish news stories giving us the Stornoway perspective on Carla Bruni-Sarkozy's new dress.
58

AIasdair,

20/10/2009 12:51:28
#52, Shoogles - what are you claiming, Joe?

That you watch BBC1 England every day, so that you can enjoy the BBC without ever accidentally flicking over and "being weegiefied" by hearing a few seconds of a Glasgow accent???

LOL.

Joe, you really are the single most pathetic and insecure weirdo out there.
59

Jimmy Fae the West,

In the Land O' Green Ginger. (HULL) 20/10/2009 12:59:44
# 57coreservers, 20/10/2009 11:54:49
sorry Nellie #47, the union was agreed between the two parliaments, however the scottish parliamentarains had "accepted" gifts and moenys from the english parliament. and it lead to nearly 50 years of uprisings and dissent. STV however has shot itself in the foot by droping things like doc martin, in this digital age, when we can just switch to itv london, wales etc. they should have created a subsudiary channel like BBC alba, which is actually very good
____________________________________
The union was never agreed to in parliament. The Scottish parliament held a ballot and rejected the union proposal! The Union was created in London by Scottish Royals and Lords who were promised a better life, better remuneration in london and hunting grounds in Scotland too.

ON TOPIC,
Scottish television hope to be competing in English with the BBC Scotland's ALBA!

Correct me if I am wrong but you are only able to access ITV-London on your digidish? All the soaps and news programs that the BBC do, ITV repeat the format and content, therefore arguing that you do not need an independent STV is to argue that you only need one soap channel and no news shows whilst you have can access BBC news 24!

STV should hold public forums and then plan their schedules around that.
60

Elephant,

Linlithgow 20/10/2009 13:06:51
Calm down dears, its only a commercial TV station!
The highlights of the STV schedule like Benidorm may have gone, but you can still find them on ITV2, and still find some great comedy in the STV schedule. Like when that wench reads out "Watch to Win" at 400mph. Cracks me up every time. She's flyin on harpic!
61

Blackheathgirl,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 13:26:32
I'm all in favour of bringing back the Bill to Scottish television. When it was replaced with another Scottish programme I turned channels!
62

Delboy,

Edinburgh 20/10/2009 13:34:33
I see Michelle McManus is now a permanent presenter of 'The Hour'. Who at STV thought that this might be a good idea?
63

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 20/10/2009 14:05:59
The EROTO_RUBRUB: What the critics said:

"I never knew Aberdeen could be this fun."

Paul Theroux

"The Bracken Den was one of our ships but we've scrapped it."

Sir Ian Wood

"I never had sex with that woman."

Chief Constable Colin McKerracher

"Henry Miller's Delta of Venus moves into the Bergen Gap."

Camille Paglia

"Flying Lorient super-kites on 400M of warp from the computer controlled split winches in force 7 and rising was breathtaking!"

Fishing News

"Arc of Prosperity Productions shot a brammer here."

The "Thistle Bar", Buckie

"We have the files and if any party is seriously guilty, call us."

Jo Beltrami
64

fritigern,

Inverness 20/10/2009 14:08:55
It is quite noticeable that the programmes STV refuses to show are dramas made in England. They are more than hapy to show old American films. But then they are trying to suck up to the virulently anti-English SNP, whose aim seems to be to turn Scotland in Western Europe's Moldova.
65

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 15:39:44
47 AT that time....considering only a tiny minority of the populace (AND NAE wimmin either) had any power to affect the political change. Oh, and slavery was legal at that time tae.
And after 12 years o' Nu Lab - th alleged 'People's Party', remember ? we still have an unelected Head of State and a unelected body tampering with laws passed by an elected body. British democracy - the envy o' the world !
66

Pilrig.,

Livingston 20/10/2009 15:45:25
66 - River City..the Bill..X Factor... Jesus, what a life !
67

Mrs Broon,

Scotland 20/10/2009 16:03:27
Yesterday Florajora asked why (the Nationalist hated people like her) I could really not be bothered answering her but after reading most of the comments from I expect are those of a unionist tendency I feel I must.
No where else is it acceptable to do your country down, to ridicule your people, to call into question their capabilities, as it seems to be among these folk.
Scottish Television may not have gone the right way about trying to bring some programmes of relevance to the population, but at least it has tried.
Now the BBC after 10 years of Devolution still persist in having their (5) minutes of opt out news on the hour and half hour and that is supposed to be sufficient. This morning after listening to Good Morning Scotland from 7 a.m. until 7.25a.m. I turned on the television and caught the lamentable fare from Glasgow which consisted of very little news, the weather report and the traffic.
This Justin and the like, is the fare we are fed in Unionist Britain. 30 minutes of everything that is happening in England and a few minutes of nothing in detail about Scotland. I know what I want and it ain't this.
68

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 20/10/2009 16:13:29
"The men o the North hae a' gane gyte"

If sitting watching the Bill is your pleasure in life, you deserve far worse than you've got so far. Meanwhile your own kids are injecting heroin supplied by Aberdeen City Detective Constabulary. This truth will come out! While the P & J distracts with a non story about the Chief Constable kissing a woman or the manager of Aberdeen FC drinking a glass of wine.

Judgement comes as inevitable as towing a trawl down a good mark. The cod end's swinging aboard and the rope will be pulled on it.
69

,

20/10/2009 16:19:42
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
70

Black Five,

edinburgh 20/10/2009 17:32:07
What a load of claptrap .The reason they are not showing the poular network programmes is because they can`t afford them.If you believe what they say just loook at Sunday`s offering.You Only Live Twice a 1967 film shown more times than I care to remember and the network gets Doc Martin.The case rests with the Jury ..I know their verdict.
71

Nellie,

Liverpool 20/10/2009 22:00:17
54 Jimmy Fae the West

LOL! No, I don't thing we should replace the Queen with the Eiffel Tower. That's funny! Not even Blackpool Tower! But I don't think we should replace her with a President ... they don't bring in any tourists!
72

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 20/10/2009 23:15:22
Democracy dissipates into very large numbers where one bedmes a mere statistic. Part of the UK's overpaid lazy uncompetitve workforce while bankers are bustin' their gut to keep us off the streets to blether and loaf at our place of work. In this rapidly changing age, 4 years is well plenty for President of Scotland to prove any competence. In a little country like ours Parliament could resign'm if he started throwing foamies and took to stalking the corridors of power and Holyrood Park in a state of ultra-glaikitness.

As President I would nationise tourism and buy you a free drink if you wandered into the Central Bar where my nobel prize winning team manage macro-economics with unostacious expertise.
73

,

20/10/2009 23:25:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
74

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 20/10/2009 23:46:58
It needs the quiet authority of a woman to handle large quadrapeds. An Australian slip o a lassie recently crossed Australia with a herd of camels.

The great bull of Europe looks an unruly beast but Florajora, Nellie, Newtonmoric Liz and Linda my farming neighbour would take it by the nose ring to its proper pen. La Confédération Paysanne will back any or all these candidates for President of Europe. We have the tractors, we own les Champs Elysee!
75

Royster,

21/10/2009 01:20:17
#69. Usual slurs from Mrs Broon I see. Of course Scots have achieved an awful lot more being in the Union than when they were out.
76

BorderLineScottish,

23/10/2009 12:43:02
Fo okin 'ell!

I spend MONTHS away from this place and I thought, "let's see what the fuss is regarding STV" apart from the fact that it's signed it's own death warrant by axing decent programs and replacing them with absolute garbage that not even the Scots want to watch!

And guess what...it's yet another Unionist/Nats hi-jacked thread.

Nothing changes and that's why independence can't come quick enough for those south of the border!

F@ cking borrrrriiinnnngggg!
77

Tr1xx,

Edinburgh 12/11/2009 10:06:11
Indeed, thank goodness for Virgin Channel 853 (ITV London). I never watch STV now and good riddance too.

Doc Martin, Benidorm, Collision, etc., etc., need I go on?

If only River City could be moved from BBC to STV.

The STV opt-out is a disaster for Scotland.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.