Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


CalMac hoping for smooth sailing with Sunday service

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 July 2009
FERRY operator Caledonian MacBrayne will breach the last bastion of Sabbatarianism in the Outer Hebrides this weekend with its first Sunday sailing from Lewis.
The state-owned operator announced yesterday it plans regular return services between Stornoway and Ullapool, leaving traditionalists angry and claiming they have not been properly consulted.

The first Sunday service will depart Stornoway at 2:30p
m in time to cater for crowds leaving the Hebridean Celtic Festival in Lewis, which ends on Saturday night. CalMac previously avoided running Sunday sailings to or from Lewis because of the strict religious belief of many islanders.

However, in May it said it had received legal advice that the practice of not providing seven-day sailings was likely to fall foul of the Equality Act 2006.

The company says ferry traffic is also rising and passengers have complained that they cannot get on the Saturday and Monday sailings on the Stornoway/Ullapool route.

Peter Timms, the CalMac chairman, said one return trip on Sundays would minimise the impact on the culture and amenity of the islands, while providing economic and social benefits.

He added: "We remain acutely aware of the sensitivities surrounding Sunday sailings, but we cannot operate unlawfully, nor fail to provide lifeline services when there is a growing demonstrable demand from the communities we serve."

It was revealed yesterday that the Scottish Government approved the proposal the day after a CalMac board meeting to discuss it. Phil Preston, CalMac's managing director, said: "The Scottish Government gave us the nod to go ahead. They have never expressed their feelings. It is an operational matter for the company."

Mr Preston said that only one member of staff – a shoreside worker in Stornoway – had raised concerns about working on a Sunday and their wishes will be respected. Police have also been informed about the start of the service this Sunday in case of protests.

"We have given an assurance that we are not going to make a celebration of this", he said.

Last night, bookings were already being made for the inaugural Sunday service.

A Scottish Government spokesman said ministers approved the request for Sunday ferries because of the concern over breaching equality laws.

He added: "This was a legal and operational matter for the company to consider."

The decision was welcomed by some last night. Uisdean Macleod, spokesman for the seven-day sailing campaign, said: "There will be the minimum amount of disruption. I don't think it will change the ethos of the island."

And Donald John MacSween, a councillor and Labour's Westminster candidate for the Western Isles, said the move was "common sense".

He added: "I think the majority of islanders will welcome this, in the same way as they did with the introduction of Sunday flights. There was some opposition to them at the beginning – but none now."

But Comhairle nan Eilean Siar (Western Isles Council) expressed "deep disappointment" at the decision.

Angus Campbell, the council leader, said: "This is not a matter of surprise, but it is still a disappointment. I am particularly unhappy that Caledonian MacBrayne have refused to meaningfully consult with the wider comhairle; nor have they provided us with the legal advice that they have based the decision upon."

The Lord's Day Observance Society has also vowed to fight the move and has retained the leading QC Gordon Jackson.

Ian Macrae, of the LDOS, said: "I am very disappointed. CalMac is riding roughshod over the democratic elected representatives of Lewis and Harris."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 July 2009 12:37 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Caledonian MacBrayne
 
1

Tracker,

15/07/2009 00:10:44
Already people are booking tickets for the Sunday sailing, so clearly there is demand. The religious dogma used by the Lords Day Observation Society to justify their opposition to Sunday sailings is risible. They should stop trying to spoil things for the rest of us.
2

Colin Wilson,

Aberdeen 15/07/2009 06:37:39
"The Lord's Day Observance Society has also vowed to fight the move and has retained the leading QC Gordon Jackson."

Nowhere in the Bible does it say that Sunday is the Lord's Day. The Biblical Sabbath is from sunset on Friday to sunset on Saturday.
3

Angoos,

Baku, Azerbaijan 15/07/2009 06:41:50
#1 Tracker

Of course they already have bookings given that the Hebridean Celtic Festival ends on Saturday.

This decision by Cal Mac has nothing to do with equality laws and everything to do with turning a profit during the tourist season.

No doubt some feeble excuse, along the lines of "as a compromise deal with the LDOS we will only permit Sunday sailings between May and September" will be given by Cal Mac during the Winter months when they cancel Sunday sailings due to the lack of bookings.
4

Cnoc,

Cnoc 15/07/2009 07:41:31
Why cannot outsiders simply respect a local culture and way of life? Why do they have to impose their southern urban ways on a remote community? Once again the views of people on the Island are not even consulted on what they want. Instead it is imposed upon them.

This is the death of the uniqueness and beauty of Lewis. Now Lewis becomes just like everywhere else, so why should visitors come to our Island. No longer does have the Unique Selling Point (no pun intended)

So in my sadness, I await the vitrol of the liberals, the incomers and those who have sold their birthrights for a mess of potage.
5

Andrew Morton,

Berkshire 15/07/2009 08:18:53
4 Cnoc,Cnoc

"Southern urban ways"? Bit harsh for those from the Orkneys and Shetlands.

I take it it's a case of "This is a local island for local people"?

If that's the case, should we stop the state run ferry service altogether since it's owned by the state and therefore we all have a share in it and Lewis can run it's own ferry company?

BTW, will having a sunday sailing prevent you from undertaking your usual Sunday activities?

"This is the death of the uniqueness and beauty of Lewis. Now Lewis becomes just like everywhere else, so why should visitors come to our Island. No longer does have the Unique Selling Point (no pun intended)"

Do you see the circle in your argument? You can't sell something you A)deny access to and B) don't own.
6

donald,

glasgow 15/07/2009 08:30:34
#Nowhere in the bible does it say that Labour's Gordon Jackson is a socialist.

Calmac deserves to be dragged, kicking and screaming, into the 19th century.
7

Douglas,

Bathgate 15/07/2009 08:31:02
I fear much stern staring and arm folding to follow.
Classes in giant, man shaped basket weaving are being monitored by a lone police sergeant.
8

Calum Crubag,

15/07/2009 08:38:14
4- an Cnoc - southern ways? Are you referring to the Uibhistich or the Sgiathanaich? Both Uist and Skye seem to work well with Sunday sailings. Anyway, the Sabbath in the bible refers to Saturday, so i assume you've been doing it wrong all those years! Prepare for hell, boy!

Co-dhiù, there's lots of Leodhasaich who want a normal life too without superstition. Let's face it, no-one is forcing you to sail. You still have the freedom to worship whatever god you wish. Just let those who've moved on from the dark ages to live life.
9

Calum Crubag,

15/07/2009 08:40:07
Gordon Jackson - here's a man who knows about potage! A man of the lord? Aye, right. Down with liberals, up with christian fascists? De man a chanas tu sin sa Ghàidhlig?!
10

Cnoc,

Cnoc, Point, IoL 15/07/2009 08:45:41

In fairness to my norse cousins in the Northern Isles, I dont think it is anyone from there who is seeking to impose a ferry on Sunday upon us.

People come to Lewis for the raw beauty, its unspoilt beaches, its tranquility. With a Sunday ferry all of that changes. Petrol stations open, suppliers start deliveries, restaurants open = the culture changes.

Mr Morton, the history of Lewis is one of imposition from the mainland; of disrespect for local people; of disconnecting those live there on making choices for the locality. Why would you deny this? Why do you support riding rough-shod over the Comhairle? Why do you want to make Lewis like a anywhere else on the mainland on a Sunday?

Grammatically, I am not sure this sentence makes much sense: "If that's the case, should we stop the state run ferry service altogether since it's owned by the state and therefore we all have a share in it and Lewis can run it's own ferry company?".

Though I can see your slightly odd argument. To summarise is this, forget the views of the Comhairle, and local people. Instead the views of a public company seeking to maximise profit are more credible and reliable. Ram this down the throats of locals, until they have to accept it. I think, Sir, you are not a democrate and you disrespect the rule of law.

Visitors have always come to Lewis, not to make Lewis into the mainland but rather to appreciate the difference. As from Sunday that difference will disappear.
11

Andrew Morton,

Berkshire 15/07/2009 08:54:17
10 Cnoc,Cnoc,

I see, so it's a case of come to Lewis to enjoy our unique Sunday but you are not allowed to either come or leave Lewis on a Sunday nor do anything that is a sign of disrespect for the local church goers?

Fair enough.

I'll head to the Uists, Skye and Barra for my empty, unspoilt beaches and tranquility instead and I will travel on a Sunday to do so and I shall leave the fair people of Lewis to thier own Sunday meanderings without "outside" interference.
12

Jings MacCrivvens,

15/07/2009 09:04:41
Hold a local referundum to settle this tedious issue once and for all.
13

Lewis Lad,

15/07/2009 10:06:54
Just to keep Cnoc informed as well as the rest of us living in the real/free world
I take it you are not aware that we can buy petrol on a Sunday and some people buy it on the way to or from Church (shock Horror what would the LDOS say about that not seen any protests or boycotts at the pumps) And even some restaurants as well as a shop or two are open so is a ferry actually going to change anything as the planes flying on a Sunday certainly haven't.
If you do not wish to do something on any day of the week you are not forced to do so. So why are Sundays different?
14

Logie Almond,

15/07/2009 10:09:19
I can remember the swings being chained up in the parks on Sundays and I am absolutely delighted that the last stronghold of bigoted religion in Scotland is now being threatened. As they say, Scotland will not be free until the last minister is strangled with the last copy of the Sunday Post.
15

fiferjohn,

15/07/2009 10:54:34
as someone that who job is involed in the tourist trade this is good news it will mean that i might get more work so i can keep my family out of poverty and not have to worry if my work is going to go bust with the lack of tourist and business.
that is the thing about the ldos has long has you worship the sabbath it does not matter if you cant feed and keep a roof over your head and you should be glad of it.
16

eamon,

15/07/2009 11:17:27
I grew up with the chained up swings and the hell fire and brimstone sabbaths, and it was hell sometimes. Especially at my cousins house where no TV, games or playing outside was allowed. All we did was go for a family walk after church, followed by a family dinner before a chat and bed. When I left the islands for the mainland I loved the fact shops were open, bars were open, you could work sunday and earn good money. But now i have a family myself I miss the togetherness of sunday. Not the church, but the fact you were guaranteed one day a week with the family. I can see the benefits of sunday sailings but can also see why some feel it will be the end of something special.I dont agree with the poster who calls the religious people of the islands bigots though, I think some manners, and some knowledge of the people he is insulting, may be needed.
17

Iain Mac,

15/07/2009 11:55:22
#16 - you make some good points. Relaxation on a Sunday need not mean shops. It should be remembered the Lord's Day nutters seek to prevent people from doing anything on the 'Sabbath' that does not include worshiping their god. People watching telly, doing washing, walking on those beaches, playing football with their kids is all forbidden.

A Siarach friend of mine had a leaflet of Calvin's maxims on religion pushed through her door because she'd left her washing out all Saturday night and it was still there on the Sunday!

Let's have Sunday ferries, NOW!
18

fiferjohn,

15/07/2009 12:11:33
#17 that is secterian abuse so she should have reported it to the police.
19

The Diplomat,

EDINBURGH 15/07/2009 13:03:09
Let's not forget it was CEH/Western Isles Council who voted for Lewis to be assaulted on all fronts by windfarms! Where is their arguement about the sanctity of their island and its life now? Just glad that L&H have been dragged into the 20th century - now only 100 years behind the rest of civilistaion.
20

Chris M,

Eilean Leodhas 15/07/2009 13:04:56
# 4 Cnoc Sell my birthright? Indeed not! I'll still spend Sunday as I do now, but should I want to leave the island on a Sunday or come home from holiday on a Sunday, then I'll have the freedom to do so. Likewise, should a member of my family fall ill, then we'll have the option to travel to see them. Not everyone can afford the airfares, even with the ADS scheme benefits.

Don't go blaming it all on the "incomers", there are plenty of island folk who wanted a Sunday ferry, including one of the Point Councillors, DJ MacSween.

Perhaps Cnoc would also do well to remember that the days of the Minister being the most educated person (and perhaps most feared?) in the Parish are long gone. Parishoners are now able to read and write for themselves and equally are able to express an opinion, irrespective of where they happen to have been born, or brought up. Time moves on, so should the churches otherwise the pews will become empty.
21

The Diplomat,

EDINBURGH 15/07/2009 13:12:47
Re # 20 - spot on! But as you say - "Time moves on, so should the churches otherwise the pews will become empty". Forgive the pun but that ship has already sailed!
22

fiferjohn,

15/07/2009 13:53:43
just been listening to the j vine on radio and that mclean is one arrogant bloke .the only one that is abusing power is him and the church playing on the fear of the church goers.
23

Chris M,

15/07/2009 15:30:48
I've just listened to Jeremy Vine's Radio 2 programme on the Listen Again facility and the two people that spoke were Uisdean Macleod, pro-Sunday ferry and John Macleod anti-Sunday ferry. No Maclean spoke.

John Macleod, the "steaming, frankly" freelance journalist who writes for the Scottish Daily Mail and was speaking on behalf of "the peasants of the North West, the poor Highlanders, the simple backward Sabbatarian Teuchters"

Aye? I wonder how many Free Church goers would describe themselves as Mr Macleod portrayed them this afternoon?

Well you can listen for yourself at

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00lk1hl/Jeremy_Vine_15_07_2009/

and starting at 1 hour 35 mins & 15 seconds in
24

fiferjohn,

15/07/2009 15:45:30
#23 couldn't hear the name properly as some work mates where going hear hear the minute he came on.

yes there are wee frees that would describe themselves as macleod portrayed
25

,

15/07/2009 15:59:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

radge dug,

15/07/2009 16:44:35
John Macleod is an amadan. Let's have the ferries now.

If the Wee Frees' faith is so strong, why don't they pray for divine intervention? Or would that just be ridiculous now?!
27

Andrew,

15/07/2009 18:37:12
Are these the same complaining folks who (presumably) would expect the police, fire or ambulance service, doctor/midwife, coastguard etc. etc., to turn out if required on a Sunday or would they (hold-fire) wait until 00.01 on a Monday morning before summoning assistance?? Mmm? I doubt it!
The ferry is just another VITAL public service like all the aforementioned! If you don't like it on Sundays, don't do it/use it on Sundays!
28

eamon,

15/07/2009 19:09:13
#17 Iain Mac

Yes I agree the ferry should run on sundays. But I do feel the people calling the wee frees bigots and the like need to remember their manners. Thats my, and your, people they are talking about. When the sunday ferry to Skye started my mother was against it, she has never said a bad word about anybody or anything, and she is definately not a bigot. But if either side feel the need to trade insults without even knowing who they are talking about, it says more about themselves than anybody else.

Far an taine 'n abhainn, 's ann as mo a fuaim.
29

danbob,

15/07/2009 23:33:58
I invited a friend who lives in Canada to read this news story and the comments in order to see what Scotland has become. Shocked isn't the word. "Has it really become so bigoted that the country is at war with itself" He wasn't refering to the story either, he was refering to the comments.
30

radge dug,

16/07/2009 12:54:33
#28 - my folks were auld Scots' presbyterians too and as much as i love them, some of their views were bigoted and outdated. And, some of the Wee Free's views are the same with their endless talk of 'sodomites' running the country! Quote from the Ferry Reverend Smith himself!

It's time for the religious to accept that we don't live according to their laws anymore. Move on.
31

eamon,

17/07/2009 14:53:08
#30

I agree, we do need to move on, and the Reverend Smith with his sodomites running the country talk should be laughed at. Especially since the one actually running the country is a son of the manse, although not, I dont think anyway, a sodomite.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.