Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Store wars brewing as chains bid for empty Woolies site

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 25 April 2009
A STORE war is brewing between rival supermarkets vying for the vacant Woolworths shop in Stockbridge.
Edinburgh-based Scotmid today said it had agreed a five-year deal with Woolies' administrator to take over the empty unit.

However, it is understood the deal has still to be approved by the building owner – leaving the door open for rival supermarket Sainsbury's.

The Evening News has learned that Tesco has also expressed interest in the site, though is not understood to have progressed as far as the other supermarkets.

Scotmid's plan is to relocate its existing shop on Hamilton Place to the former Woolworths store and convert its old premises to a Semi Chem store.

A Keep Stockbridge Local campaign was launched when Sainsbury's interest in the Woolworths site was first revealed, with residents raising concerns that a supermarket on Raeburn Place would threaten local independent food stores.

Campaigners today welcomed the Scotmid move.

Tannis Dodd, owner of Herbie's deli and a member of Stockbridge and Inverleith Community Council, said: "The point is that Scotmid is already established in the community, it is a known quantity and this way means that we will not be getting yet another supermarket in Stockbridge.

"The campaign has shown that people here are interested in keeping Stockbridge local, it is something special we have here."

Stockbridge is already served by a small Scotmid and a Waitrose. The Sainsbury's store at Craigleith is just a mile away, and there is a Tesco at Broughton Road.

A petition against Sainsbury's moving into the area has attracted more than 4000 signatures.

A spokesman for Scotmid said: "We are quite clear that we have agreed a five-year deal with the administrator, with a view to agreeing something longer term.

"The strength of local feeling on this gave us the confidence to go ahead with the deal and we feel it is a good move for Stockbridge."

The Keep Stockbridge Local campaign has been investigating the idea of setting up a community trust to come up with alternative uses for the empty retail site.

The last major battle against a supermarket in Edinburgh saw the Portobello Campaign Against The Superstore campaign successfully fight plans for a supermarket to be built at the old ScottishPower HQ on Portobello High Street.

Woolworth's administrator Deloitte declined to comment on the future of the Stockbridge store.

A Sainsbury's spokesman said: "Sainsbury's has been in discussions with the administrators and landlord of the former Woolworths store in Stockbridge.

"To date, a sale or rental agreement on the lease has not been concluded.

"We remain confident that a Sainsbury's Local would be a complimentary fit in Stockbridge and a positive addition to the area, both attracting consumers to, and retaining trade in, Stockbridge."


Page 1 of 1

 
1

Mikko,

Drumnadrochit 25/04/2009 11:16:24
I thought Tesco is now more important than God. But then I am in Inverness.
2

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 25/04/2009 12:04:06
I am very glad that Tesco have taken an interest,i would like that.
3

Daudi Baldrs,

Norway 25/04/2009 12:17:28
#1

If you need some cans of beer and a ten pack of Value fish fingers, Tesco IS more important than God.

That may be a secular view, but it's a practical one.
4

Chuck.U.Farley,

25/04/2009 12:31:36
"Tannis Dodd owner of Herbie's deli"
No vested interest in keeping Tesco/Scotmid/Sainsbury out of Stockbridge then?
5

Leila,

Edinburgh 25/04/2009 13:15:21
I'm afraid I don't see the logic of the argument that a Scotmid supermarket would be OK on Raeburn Place, but a Sainsburys supermarket would not, given that the size of the premises and presumably the range of goods for sale would be the same.
6

Auld Reeky,

25/04/2009 13:21:02
I understand that Scotmid is currently closed at Hamilton Place for a major re-furbishment of its store and not open until 1st May, so I do not see they would be interested in moving to ex-Woolies site in a hurry, so hopefully Sainsbury's will take it on and bring a bit of "cheapness with quality" service to the Area which unfortunately neither local traders or Scotmid do at present.
7

Fifi la Bonbon,

25/04/2009 14:19:17
Why haven't we heard from Lidl or Aldi? I'm presently munching on a luncheon comprising Lidl tortillas with Lidl ham. It's awful nice, and the ham was half price. But I couldn't have got that in Stockbridge.
8

Former Woolworths Stockbridge employee,

Edinburgh 25/04/2009 15:07:02
Great... so Scotmid are possibly moving into my store and they will transfer all their current staff from across the road into my store leaving all us Woolies staff STILL out a job!! Opening another bloody Scotmid will do NOTHING to help the situation of unemployment for either the 30,000 redundant Woolworths staff or the rest of the economy! Does anyone even like the Scotmid thats currently there? Scotmid has a monopoly in the area and therefore can afford to provide poor customer service and poor store standards... Why do they feel Scotmid is ANY better??? They are the 5th largest supermarket in the UK, how is this keeping Stockbridge local?

Personally I would welcome a Sainsburys and think it would fit in well. Or how about a Tesco Home? Just because these companies express interest doesn't mean they are going to open the typical supermarket..

Realistically what does Deloitte have to do with the situation? They couldn't organise a drinking session in a Brewery!! The amount of contradictory information we received from them was a joke - "sell your cages"; "don't sell the cages, return to DC"; "sell the cages"; "cages are leased, don't sell". Or how about the one we got our behinds kick for "Send your Risk Management File to DC" yet when our Administrator rep came into store they hit the roof when they found out it wasn't on site despite being shown the emil in question!! WASTERS! Surely its up to the landlord... who we met and said "If I were you I'd apply to......" I'll leave you with that! Don't want to spoil the fun!
9

Bonnyblink,

Edinburgh 25/04/2009 16:42:16
There is already a Scotmid in Reaburn Place right opposite the ex Wollies store..................
10

Chuck.U.Farley,

25/04/2009 16:51:30
No sh@t Sherlock..............it already states that in the story!
11

JT,

25/04/2009 17:54:00
I think Lidls/Aldi should go in and really stir things up!! Imagine the shock on the Stockbridge mafia. Stockbridge is not the blue rinse brigade area that it once was and it should move with the times. Here in Gorgie/Dalry we have sainsbugs,asda, lidl and scotmid (which is rank but there in a complete emergency)and we are getting an Aldi which should really shake things up. Why shouldnt people have choice.
12

Glenda,

blah 25/04/2009 18:29:24
Agree with #12. Scotmid in Gorgie is a wee dump - same as most other Scotmids which have a dull, dog-eared, dusty feel about them.

Can't wait for the new Aldi in Gorgie. Best deli stuff you can get at rock bottom prices. Stockbridge deserves one too.
13

Nemetor,

Lothian 25/04/2009 19:28:06
#8 - Not 5th largest in UK, this is Scotmid Co-operative, not Co-operative. Scotmid are a 150yr old Co-operative started in Edinburgh and still based in Edinburgh.

Hamilton Place store remains and undergoing major refit as mentioned.

Raeburn Place store closes and relocates over the road - staff will transfer but will obviously need more staff - feel free to apply as anyone else looking for a job would do.

Semichem moves into vacant Scotmid unit in Raeburn Place.

The difference being that the number of food operators does not change where there would be an increase if Sainsburys moved in.

Simples.
14

The Sheriff,

25/04/2009 19:56:37
I say turn it into a job centre plus superstore so the moaning ex employees of woolies can apply for a job with scotmid.

In other words who gives a monkey who takes over the store,better some business does rather than see it stay empty like a blot on the landscape.

In fact knock it down and build a two storey carpark to clear raeburn place of all the cars that cause gridlock.
15

,

25/04/2009 21:01:28
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

The new waspy,

25/04/2009 21:40:18
#16
Dont knock ex employees for feeling bad, after all it was a large part of their life earning a wage to supportt themselves which judging by your selfish comments you are not working and probably never have!!!!!!!
17

elayne,

25/04/2009 22:33:55
may the best store win!if it brings work for people,fine!
18

wolfette,

Edinburgh 26/04/2009 00:52:56
I'm betting it will be a Lidl store before too much longer.

19

Aslan,

Edinburgh 26/04/2009 00:53:10
#17 -'I aint being racist' ... nah, you ARE!
20

Douglas,

Bathgate 26/04/2009 00:59:40
#15 Nemetor: I have this day despatched box of "the" to your address.
Please use them as required.
21

Auld Reeky,

26/04/2009 09:36:49
#15 The aritcle reads that Scotmid intends to relocate from Hamilton Place to Woolies site and that what was Hamilton Place store will become a Semi-Chem no mention is made of Raeburn Place current store, or do you know something else????
22

The Sheriff,

26/04/2009 10:41:43
The New Waspy....I've worked all my life since leaving school in 1981 so your mind blowing thoughts that i have neither worked or am currently working are indeed that...mind blowing.

Now run along...
23

David Harrington,

Edinburgh 26/04/2009 12:32:58
It seems that some of the Stockbridge shops wish to be protected from competition by the likes of Sainsbury in order to protect their sales of overpriced goods; having realised they might have been rumbled they are now running scared and using "local" as a pretence to oppose legitimate competition. If they have something unique to offer customers they will still come.
24

New Town's newest fan,

26/04/2009 17:25:32
Why not turn it into a charity hyper-market to fit in with the rest?
25

Julian.,

edinburgh 26/04/2009 23:50:38
David Harrington,

And how about the 4000 who signed the petition. Are they all vested interests linked to local shops?
26

blackley,

Edinburgh 27/04/2009 08:33:50
They should knock it down and build some flats - badly needed in the area.
27

thats it,

edinburgh 27/04/2009 16:05:43
24 The Sheriff: yes i have worked all my days since leaving school 15 years IN WOOLWORTHS until it closed. I dont care who goes into my old shop as long as someone does.oh and i do have a job now with a big pay cut but you've gotta take what you can now...
28

Former Woolworths Stockbridge employee,

Edinburgh 27/04/2009 17:32:39
Suppose at this point I just want to see someone in it! I'll take a Scotmid I suppose! As for "The Sheriff" - I have a job thanks!
29

Nemetor,

Lothian 27/04/2009 20:51:14
#22 - no idea what you are on about.

#23 - the article is not accurate.

Hamilton Place remains Scotmid, Raeburn Place Scotmid becomes Semichem. Woolworths site becomes Scotmid.
30

Bling Crosby,

Edinburgh 02/06/2009 12:12:41
i hate Scotmid.

it is run by tinks and smells of urine.
31

Lens,

Stockbridge 06/06/2009 18:43:10
I know why the local shop owners don't object to Scotmid - it isn't a threat because the quality of produce is so poor. Aside from ethics they are one of the worst supermarkets.

I don't know who these mysterious 4000 petitioners are, but they presumably don't try to shop in Stockbridge. Will they release this petition for geospatial scrutiny? I bet half of them do their weekly shopping at one of the big chains anyway.

My message to the local shop owners is: try being open when 90% of the working people in the area actually want to buy something. I work until at least 6pm every day, and my only option to get something for tea is Scotmid, where I find myself pacing around looking for some simple ingredients, then going home with something distinctly unappetising. I went in to Herbies close to closing time the other night and I couldn't have felt less welcome, which is ironic considering how much cash I pour into their various shops - not exactly the "local" feeling they are appealing for us to preserve.

Having Herbies man as the spokesperson here is laughable. They might sell some nice produce, but it's hardly day-to-day stuff (unless you are a lottery winner) - best part of 5 quid for a quarter of brie!! The bread is superb though, so I would probably still buy that regardless of the supermarkets.

One well-known local greengrocer suffers from reliability issues. If the owner is there, the quality is generally good; when a friend or relative is running the show, it's pretty dreadful.

The butcher and fish-monger are excellent, but again, 9-5 is when most of their potential clientele are earning the money they want us to spend - stay open later!

Independent wine shop, flower shops etc are also good - can be expensive - but no complaints really.

I can't express how disappointed I am to be getting another Scotmid. They did up the Hamilton Place store a few weeks ago, and it's still rubbish. Still regularly has little or no fresh meat or vegetables (at
32

Lens,

Stockbridge 06/06/2009 18:46:02
cont...

(at least not at the same time). They used to have at least have a decent wine selection, but that's gone.

This might all seem parochial and middle class - it is - which is why Sainsbury's or Tesco would be a much better fit! A small offering from either of these wouldn't kill the local shops, but it might give them a kick up the bum.

So, local shop owners, don't rely on a captive market or the mediocrity of your competition - make an effort to serve the demographic and loyalty will follow.
33

Ian Ross,

13/07/2009 14:14:23
There is already a perfectly good supermarket almost opposite the old Woolies store that nobody has mentioned. There is also a Waitrose along the road at Comely Bank. So the last thing Stockbridge needs is yet another Supermarket!
34

Red Ken,

South East Asia 30/07/2009 12:57:46
According to my spies the Scotmid store already has the shop fitters in and its due to open sometime next week. Looks like the Evening News needs a bit of help in researching the story.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.