Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


10 ways that Labour can start getting things right

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 May 2008
PRIME Minister Gordon Brown can this weekend be forgiven for biting his fingernails as he surveys the wreckage of the local elections, where Labour was booted out of council seats across huge swathes of England, saw its power base in Wales disintegrate and looked on helplessly as the Conservative Boris Johnson was crowned in the most powerful civic seat in the UK.
If he believes his oft-repeated mantra that Britain has never before enjoyed such a prolonged period of economic growth, and that millions of families are better off than ever, he must be stunned.

It's not such a puzzle for the rest of us, though.
Soaring mortgage costs for those who can get one, and the mounting prospect of repossession for those who can't, is a good place to begin. Spice that up with falling house prices in many parts of the country, and soaring holiday costs as the pound falls, and you start to get the flavour.

Stir in the 10p tax row, rising fuel and food bills and the pensions crisis and you've concocted a cauldron of hubble, bubble, toil and trouble.

And if revenge is a dish best served cold, the voters of England and Wales certainly took it on Thursday.

Does this mean Labour will lose the next general election? Far from it. We suggest 10 things Labour has to start getting right to come back from the dead.

1. Cut stamp duty to kick start the housing market

While property prices are holding up in Scotland, they are tumbling like last week's rain in many other parts of the UK as buyers flee in panic.

Mortgage broker John Postlethwaite at PSFM in Edinburgh suggests Chancellor Alistair Darling should cut stamp duty to encourage first-time buyers to take the plunge and get transactions moving.

Or he could go one step better and declare a stamp duty holiday as the Conservatives did during the last property recession in 1991 for all homes under £250,000. In today's prices that would allow buyers to escape the hated tax on all property under about £700,000.

2. Cut interest rates to slash the cost of mortgages

Charcol's Ray Boulger said: "The Government keeps chiming on about our historically low interest rates, but it isn't true. After allowing for inflation, our interest rates are expensive. They must come down."

The latest Bank of England figures reveal that some six million borrowers on fixed deals are paying the highest interest in eight years.

Boulger also suggests helping those with negative equity to move, which will also help free up the market. He said: "Politicians and banks always do the reverse of what is needed. Mortgages for 125% of the value of a property came into being during the old days of negative equity, so borrowers could still move and take their negative equity with them.

"Yet now when we see negative equity for the first time since the early 1990s, and we really need these loans again, they have been withdrawn."

3. Sort out the tax mess by raising personal allowances

Increasing the tax paid by those earning below £19,500 has caused huge anger. Grant Thornton's Mike Warburton suggested: "Let people keep more of what they earn, through higher allowances, rather than taking it away and then giving it back via a complex web of reliefs. We need far more clarity."

4. Overhaul remuneration and expenses for MPs and MEPs

Those earning around the average wage of £26,000 and below have been disgusted at the lurid tales of MPs, who already earn not far short of £70,000, claiming hundreds of thousands more in expenses to pay members of their family, fund second homes, travel on first-class trains and otherwise enjoy the kind of lifestyle most of their voters can only dream of – largely paid for by those on average wages or less.

5. Tackle pensions inequality in the private and public sectors

This might include raising state employees' retirement age to 68, as with the rest of the population, breaking the link with salary for new employees and removing the automatic tax-free cash enhancement which comes on top of the pension.

6. Cut fuel duties

Big, ugly truckers are transformed by the camera into cuddly, caring teddy bears. Expect to see more of them and their roadblocks unless petrol prices come down. Drivers everywhere are hurting.

7. Stop increasing taxes on private pensions

Last month's 2p cut in the basic rate of tax from 22p to 20p will reduce the tax rebate going into private pensions by several hundred million pounds a year, cutting the retirement income of seven million employees.

At the Budget, Darling announced a special concession to charities: they are still to receive a 22p rather than 20p rebate. A similar concession for pension contributions would take some of the sting out of the change for pensions.

8. Reverse the tax hike for employee share save schemes

PSFM chairman Geoff Tresman said: "There is something very wrong when wealthy buy-to-let investors and entrepreneurs enjoy substantial tax cuts in their capital gains tax bill while the checkout workers at Asda see tax on their modest company savings schemes rise from 10% to 18%. Reversing this would be a very simple measure."

9. Sort out council tax

Voters are fed up with handing over thousands of pounds a year to have their rubbish collected only once a fortnight.

10. Whatever you do, don't buy any more banks

Stop both the knee-jerk reactions and dithering, and lose the paranoia. Listen to the advice of the professionals. Had Brown and Darling consulted tax experts before implementing the recent changes, most of the mess associated with scrapping the 10p band and reforming CGT might have been avoided.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 May 2008 2:46 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Tedz,

South of the Border 04/05/2008 02:28:16
The "ten points" may sound reasonable - but won't actually do anything. If other papers are to be believed Brown was warned by the Treasury that getting rid of the 10p band was not a good idea. He didn't listen.

The Government needs to start taking popularist steps. And fast. As well as dealing with interest rates it needs to become the consumer's champion. Why does it take individuals and the OFT to take on Banks and their charges - what's wrong with quick and speedy legislation? Check out the Irish Republic - customers are protected from the Banks there, but not here. Government silence. And, a maximum interest rate on personal borrowing will help many thousands who use expensive credit. It won't cost the Government a penny but will give them much needed bonus points.

The new road tax system needs ditching fast. (Anyone on here certain what they will be paying next year?). My road tax will be up by almost 50%. It's an older car (like most of Labour's core supporters) and I'm going to get hammered by this new system. In turn, I will hammer the Government. Motorists are the new evil. Stop large fines and points for minor speeding offences. Control (not stop) the use of speed cameras.

Look at National Insurance contributions. Sir Paul McCartney (sorry Paul, had to pick someone), stopped paying NI on his earned income when he hit 65. So, his maximum deduction is 40% tax. My paltry earnings are taxed (tax and NI) at a maximum of 31%. Err, why should there be only 9% difference bewteen me and Paul McCartney? He's on £xM a year and I'm on £17K. NI is an age related tax and it is unfair to stop NI on earned income after 65.

Another blindingly obvious vote winner is making sure NHS dentistry is actually available. Government Ministers trot out the same line the Tories did before they lost office. They were excellent sound bites but if you can't get an NHS dentist they mean nothing and won't stop me voting anything other than Labour.

Just a couple of extra w
2

Evan Owen,

Snowdonia 04/05/2008 08:52:22
"He didn't listen"

What an epitaph..

What a shambles, now farmers and others who use a 4X4 to tow all those various trailers, some full of animals, will go back to a lorry because the VED is lower, this means more pollution and thousands of cars sitting around waiting to be scrapped.

This government didn't listen to the people, it will listen to what the ballot box has to say but will it learn? They have messed too many people around.
3

The Strategist,

04/05/2008 08:53:43
I've no idea who Teresa Hunter but her suggestions are a recipe for allowing the banks to screw up our economy all over again.......
4

it has always been allan,

04/05/2008 10:25:59
Brown will never resign, just like a certain other megalomanaic.

He cannot begin to see that he could have made mistakes.
5

Roger McTain,

Glasgow 04/05/2008 18:09:17
Why kick-start an over-inflated housing market? The first two points could've been written by a lobbyist working a mortgage lender. Shameful.
6

Roger McTain,

Glasgow 04/05/2008 18:16:27
my comment above should've read:
written by a lobbyist working 'on behalf' of a mortgage lender
- sorry! - Roger
7

House Price Crash,

UK 04/05/2008 18:43:25
House prices falling is not the problem, it is the solution.
8

MB,

Edinburgh 04/05/2008 21:53:15
When is everyone just going to accept that the housing market is seriously overvalued and needs to level off for future sustainability? Prices reached an outlandish level last year and 20% annual growth in prices could obviously not be sustained forever. What is happening in the market now is the perfectly logical result of 5 years of irresponsible lending and speculative mal-investment. Let's all just accept the bitter medicine of a market correction and move on to let the economy become stable again.

In any case, government interference with stamp duty changes will not work. In Ireland, stamp duty rates were reduced about a year ago and yet house prices still fell around 10% there in 2007. Housing markets in the US, UK, Ireland etc all need to return to fundamentals that reflect wages and historic averages. The sooner we accept that and let the economy rebalance, the quicker the wider economy will recover.
9

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 05/05/2008 03:53:56
Here are the ten best things the Labour could do;1,Resign.2 Resign,3 Resign, 4 Resign, 5 Resign, 6 Resign, 7 Resign, 8 Resign, 9 Resign, and Finally I really must stop sitting on the fence, RESIGN!!
10

A Homeowner,

Crieff 05/05/2008 08:35:02
I can't understand Ms Hunter's obsession with keeping house prices ridiculously high. There was a similar article in the SoS a couple of weeks back. If the problem is getting first time buyers on to the property ladder, the solution is lower house prices.

And the assertion that house prices are "holding up" in Scotland suggests to me the author is either ill-informed, or deliberately misinforming. Neither of these is a particularly welcome trait in a financial "expert".

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.